Example for How to Find Your Mission Match

Last week I shared about the Mission Match – the place where a donors’ passions and interests are aligned with a portion of a nonprofit’s work.

But my explanation, and the graphic I shared, are super-conceptual.  So I want to give you a real-life example of how one international nonprofit evolved the messaging of an appeal letter to find the deepest (richest?) Mission Match between the organization and its donors.

Here’s the story…

One of the organization’s core values was education, and each spring they did an appeal focused on education.  That’s the first entry on the left above.  The appeal did… fine.

The first year I worked with them, when it came time for the Education Appeal, I counselled them to focus the appeal on providing a year’s worth of school for one child, instead of on the concept of education. 

That letter raised about twice as much money as the previous year’s appeal raised.

The next year, because of experiences I’d had with similar organizations, I counselled them to focus the appeal on “sending a girl to school for a year” instead of “sending a child to school for a year.”  The appeal raised even more money.

The following year, we’d heard from the field that one of the consequences of girls not going to school was that they were more likely to be married off and become child brides.  So we focused the appeal on “send a girl to school and make sure she doesn’t become a child bride.”  The appeal raised still more money.

The final appeal on the right edge shows the next year, when we focused the appeal on how the donor’s gift will help stop a girl from becoming a child bride.  The appeal worked great and was now raising roughly four times as much as the “education appeal.”

The Mission Match

The organization’s projects and programs didn’t change.  But how we talked about what the donor’s gift accomplished sure did. 

All of the changes we made were in search of the mission match – the part of the organization’s work that the most people would be most likely to fund.  In this case it turned out that donors were mildly interested in funding “education,” and exceptionally interested in making sure that girls didn’t become child brides.

And we went through this process with the organization’s other appeals and newsletters as well.  As you can imagine, they are raising a LOT more money today than they were at the beginning of the process.

All because they were willing to change the way they talked about their work in order to discover which part of their work donors resonated with most.

Just a Little Practice

At last week’s Nonprofit Storytelling Conference I led a session where – during the session itself – I had people write and send a fundraising email.

Think about that for a second: before they walked in the room the people did not know what their email would be about.  It wasn’t on their plan for the year.  Yet they wrote it, sent it and raised money. 

Here are a couple quick results…

  • One person sent an email to her email list of 3,300 people.  She received 4 gifts in the first 5 minutes.  The highlight was a major donor replying and saying, “I didn’t know this was going on, how much do you need?”  The email raised $67,000 in one day.
  • One person sent an email to 2,500 people, got a 48% open rate, generated 59 gifts, and raised $5,500 in two days.
    • This one’s an amazing story; the email we worked on during the session was emailed just 8 hours after their previous fundraising email.  That previous email generated zero gifts.  Talk about proof that changing your messaging can create massive increases in fundraising!
  • Another person sent her email to her “marketing” list – meaning it was only marketing contacts, none of them were donors – and acquired 5 new donors in the first day.

None of that money would have been raised, or those new donors acquired, without the bravery of the people who sent out their emails.  (There is money and new donors out there for your organization every day, too.)

My goal for the session was to have people raise enough money to cover the cost of their trip to the conference.

But really, my goal was for them to see how relatively quickly you can write and send an email and raise money.  Because the thing holding most small nonprofits back from raising money is the fear around just reaching out to donors with an opportunity for the donors to fund something meaningful.

In weight-lifting or sports it’s often called a “rep” – doing a thing and learning from it, in order to make it easier for you to do it in the future.  Just getting a smaller nonprofit to get a “rep” of writing a simple email, sending it out, and tracking the results is a great step on their way to being in touch with their donors more often and raising more money.

Most smaller nonprofits are so afraid of fundraising “too often” that they never get enough practice to create great fundraising.  For instance, there’s just no way to get great at sending fundraising emails when you only send a few a year.   

This is the painful developmental stage that stops 97% of nonprofits from ever raising more than $1m from individual donors in a year: they don’t send many clear asks to donors, so they don’t build the skill of asking well, so their appeals don’t work very well, so it’s remarkably hard to scale past a few hundred donors.

Fundraising is a skill you get better at with practice.  Helping people get over their fear in order to get some practice was the main goal underpinning my whole session. 

If you’re reading this, and you think that you or your nonprofit could get better with some practice, I encourage you to start practicing.  Write and send out an e-appeal today.  Or add one more e-appeal to your year-end fundraising, try something a little different, and track the results.

The same stream of generosity that the organizations in my session tapped into is available to you, too.

Track Everything and Learn the Patterns

I’m fresh back from last week’s Nonprofit Storytelling Conference; this post is for my small nonprofit friends out there.

At the conference I talked to several nonprofits who did not feel in control of their fundraising results.  And because it’s disheartening to work in a job where you really don’t feel in control of the outcomes, these folks were losing love for their jobs.

They’d make plans, have strategies, send out fundraising… but some years they’d raise more and some year’s they’d raise less.  Fundraising seemed more like the proverbial “black box” than something they could accel at.

The lack of control and power they felt was sapping their energy and enthusiasm. 

I’m writing this post to say that it doesn’t have to be this way.  It’s a solvable problem.  And solving it is the key to fundraising growth.

Here’s my bon mot for how to break the cycle: track everything, learn the patterns.    

This is easy to say and a lot of work at first, but it’s an investment in the only way out that I know of.

Track Everything

Here are three simple examples:      

  • Every email has a unique code so that you can isolate the performance of that email. 
  • Know your retention rate for major donors every year. 
  • Know the performance of your donation page(s), things like the # of visitors and your conversion rate.

You get it.  Think of it this way: every piece of fundraising you send out, every year of fundraising you complete, is an experiment.  If an organization isn’t tracking the results from its experiments, how can it learn? 

Learn the Patterns

Here are the types of things you’ll notice right away:

  • What types of subject lines generate higher (and lower) open rates.  Apply the learning, your open rates go up across the board, and your emails raise more money.
  • What approach to major donor management results in the most majors increasing their giving.  Apply the learnings and more of your major donors give higher gifts.
  • What asks in your letters generate higher (and lower) revenue.  Apply the learnings and every mailing starts to raise more money.

Very quickly, you know which part of your fundraising operation are working the best.  Very quickly, you can change your fundraising operation so that you do more of ‘what’s working the best’ and raise more money.

I know that this is real work for smaller nonprofits.  But I’ll share that in my 30-plus years of fundraising I’ve never seen an organization raise more than a few hundred thousand a year without doing this. 

The secondary consequence of tracking everything and learning the patterns is a sense of control.  You know that this email will do great at that time.  You know that if you handle your major donors in this way, then that percentage of them will give larger gifts this year. 

Quick story – I used to work at a big fundraising agency helping national nonprofits with their direct mail and radio fundraising.  One of my jobs each year was to look at a spreadsheet with the performance of every piece of fundraising, then make a data-driven prediction how much money would come in the following year.

Because everything had been tracked, the predictions were always accurate.  (Of course unknowable things would happen, like natural disasters or unexpected large gifts or a pallet of mail being lost by the post office, but the predictions were accurate enough to make everything easier, from budgeting to hiring staff to making program decisions.)

Anyway, that feeling of control is one of the things that made me love fundraising.  And I want it for you.

But you have to track everything and learn the patterns.

Run the Fundraising Department, Don’t Be the Fundraising Department

Almost every national nonprofit uses a fundraising agency for specialized tasks.  For the first 15 years of my career, I worked at those fundraising agencies building mail, email, radio, and TV campaigns for many national nonprofits.  It was fun, rigorous work.

So I was genuinely surprised when I started working with smaller nonprofits and found that many of them were wary of outsourcing their fundraising.  In the world I’d come from, outsourcing was simply how it was done.

Over time I came to understand two reasons smaller organizations tend to keep it all in-house.  I’m going to share them both here because I think there’s a freeing idea hiding behind them.

The first reason is cost. We hear it from nonprofit leaders all the time: “Why would we hire you? For that money we could hire a staff person who’d write our appeals and do a dozen other things we need done around here.”

That’s a great question.  It’s the same question I ask of anyone trying to sell a specialized service to Better Fundraising.

Here’s the one drawback of this question: it treats the services as equal, but they aren’t.  For instance, the staff person a nonprofit hires will write maybe four appeals this year. Our team will write around two hundred appeals this year – and then review the results, look for patterns, and keep learning what’s working in fundraising right now.

So the real choice isn’t “staff person or agency.”  It’s which path results in more net revenue.  One path costs more upfront, but the appeals raise more, and your team gets its time back for the work that only they can do.  The other path adds no expense – but the appeals tend to raise less, and your team has less time.

The second reason is more interesting.  Many nonprofits feel their work is too special, too nuanced, too unique for an outsider to really understand.  All of which is true.

But being special isn’t a reason to keep the writing in-house.  It’s a reason to make sure the writing is done well.

The large organizations don’t think their work is one bit less special or important than yours.  They think it’s so important that it deserves a specialist – someone who does direct response fundraising all day and does it well.  The large organizations have the same starting belief – “our work is unique and matters enormously” – and reach a different conclusion.

Here’s how that belief sounds when you move it to another corner of your organization. Picture a nonprofit that does its own taxes because “we’re unique, nobody on the outside could understand how our accounting works, so there’s no point hiring a tax expert.”  You’d gently point out that their uniqueness is exactly why they’d want a professional who does taxes all day – someone who catches what an amateur would miss.

You already believe this.  You just may not have aimed it at fundraising yet.  You pay for a CRM instead of building your own database.  You use an email platform instead of coding one.  Plenty of nonprofits hire fractional fundraisers to help with strategic planning, or an expert to audit their technology stack.

That’s good leadership: putting critical functions in expert hands so your team can spend its time on what only your team can do.

Which brings me to the idea I most want to hand you:

Your job isn’t to be the fundraising department. It’s to run the fundraising department.

Running it means keeping for your own team the things only your own team can do – leadership, vision, sitting across the table from a major donor, carrying the real stories out of your programs.  And it means feeling free to hand the specialized production work – the appeals, the emails, the testing and tracking – to people who do it two hundred times a year.

You’re allowed to do this.  It isn’t giving up control, and it isn’t admitting your work is ordinary.  It’s the same move the largest, most effective organizations in the country make every single day – precisely because they take their missions so seriously.

So if you’ve been carrying the whole thing yourself, consider this your permission to set some of it down.  Run the department.  Let specialists handle the specialized work.  And spend your irreplaceable hours on the handful of things that truly can only be done by you.

The Donor Pipeline

Have you heard of “the donor pipeline”?

It’s the idea that donors move through your organization on predictable pathways at predictable rates.

  • Of your first-time donors last year, a predictable percentage will give you a second gift this year.
  • Of your mass donors, a predictable percentage will become major donors.
  • Of all your donors, a predictable percentage will leave you legacy gifts.

And of course there are outliers.  The nonprofit world is full of stories of receiving legacy gifts from people they’ve never heard of, and first-time donors giving several thousand dollars.

But those are remarkable because they are rare.  You can’t build a lasting organization on gifts you don’t expect.

So, growing nonprofits actively manage their donor pipeline so they know what to expect.  Not enough mid-level donors to feed the major donor pipeline?  Time to work on your upgrade strategies.  Too low a percentage of donors giving legacy gifts?  Time to increase marketing of the legacy giving program!

This is hard for smaller nonprofits.  You’re already wearing too many hats; do you really have room for a new “Donor Pipeline Manager” hat, too?

But just the idea that you have a pipeline – and it can be managed – helps smaller nonprofits.  The amount you raise each year can sometimes feel totally out of your control, but when you realize fundraising is a knowable system you begin to have more power over it.   

So, how’s your pipeline?

Even just asking yourself that question starts you thinking about your fundraising operation in a more systematic way.

***

If you’d like help managing your pipeline, or knowing which parts of your system are in need of help, get in touch!

Fundraising Success Story

Fun success story for you.

We’ve been working with a small nonprofit on the East coast for a little over a year.

Each year they do a summer appeal, and this summer the Better Fundraising team wrote and designed the appeal.  In past years their summer appeal has raised around $5,000, and our appeal this year raised $22,000.

Another thing that’s happening for this organization is this year they’re receiving more unexpected major gifts through the mail.  (This happens often to our clients during the first year we work with them.)  One of them was a $10k check from a donor whose highest previous gift was $1,000.

In a nutshell, here’s what we’re doing for this organization:

  • We’re sending more fundraising to their donors.  We’re making sure their donors are regularly being given opportunities to help (by making a donation), and are regularly hearing about the effects of their giving.
  • We’re being clearer about what happens when funds are not raised.  We’re not sensational in the least, just speaking the truth about what happens when people are unable to receive the help they need.
  • We’ve added printed newsletters to their annual plan.  Each newsletter raises twice what it costs to print and mail.

That’s it. 

And this organization’s fundraising is WAY up! And hey, if you want to talk about how Better Fundraising can help your organization do the same thing, get in touch!

You’re Not Fundraising to a Pond, You’re Fundraising to a River

Here’s a quick tip, borrowed from the world of advertising, that will help you with your direct response fundraising:

You’re not sending your fundraising to a pond, you’re sending it to a river.

A pond holds the same water year after year.  A river doesn’t.  The water going past you today is not the water that went past you last spring.

Here’s what that looks like in your donor file.  Say your organization has a 60% donor retention rate and a stable overall number of donors.  That means 4 out of every 10 donors on your file right now were not there for last year’s Fall campaign or last year’s year-end letter.  They didn’t see it.

Now turn it around.  Of the donors who did see last year’s Fall campaign, 4 out of 10 of them have left the building.

So the group of people receiving your fundraising is not a fixed, static audience.  It’s a constantly changing group.  To add even more uncertainty, you don’t know which donor saw which pieces of your fundraising.  Maybe they were out of town during last year’s Fall campaign and never saw it.

This means that, the next time someone in a meeting says, “But we’ve already said that to our donors,” you have an accurate answer: “No, we didn’t.  We said it to about half of our donors.  And we don’t know which ones.”

Why ‘keeping it fresh’ isn’t as helpful as it feels

The desire to keep your fundraising fresh assumes your donors are a pond.  The same people, sitting in the same place, hearing the same message over and over.  (And there’s usually a fear that the donor’s finger is hovering over the “unsubscribe” or “complain” button.)

But a large share of the people who read your Fall campaign this year have never seen it before.  For them, the campaign that you are tired of is brand new to them.

Worth noticing: your staff and Board receive more of your fundraising than your donors do.  You saw all of it.  Donors saw some of it, and sometimes while busy doing other things at the same time.

You might feel tired of a message or campaign, but the feeling isn’t shared.

Instead

Find something that works and repeat it each year.

Put a higher value on finding something that works great – then updating it as needed – than on keeping things fresh each year.  The river keeps bringing you new people every year who haven’t heard it.  And the people who gave last year will likely give again.

The Soft Skills and Leadership Needed to Acquire a Lot of New Donors

Earlier this week I shared how nonprofits acquire significant numbers of new donors every year through paid acquisition.    

But to acquire new donors through paid acquisition, a nonprofit needs to demonstrate a high-level of what we might call “vision and steadfastness.”

Here’s what I mean, and I think you’ll see why a nonprofit needs some of those “softer skills” in order for paid acquisition to be a success:

  • The nonprofit must create a new line item in your budget specifically for donor acquisition.
    • This is hard for a nonprofit that already feels low on money!  This feels like a big new expense when you’re trying to run as lean as possible.
  • The acquisition program will lose money in year #1.
    • You more than make up the loss in future years.  But the people with the longer perspective will have to be just as vocal as the people who are fixated on short-term ROI and want to cancel the program.
  • Usually a nonprofit needs to do paid acquisition for at least a year before they get good at it.
    • Because buying ads, creating offers, and creating acquisition ads is a skill you have to learn through practice, your results the first year will likely be low – but you have to keep going for the investment to be worth it.

It’s easy to see why not very many nonprofits sign up for this!

I say all this because for a smaller nonprofit to start an acquisition program is a real effort in leadership and faith.    

So, How Do You Succeed?

Thankfully, tens of thousands of nonprofits have successfully gone down this path. 

Here’s what their experience tells us is necessary to succeed…

  1. The leader of the program, and often of the entire nonprofit, must talk about what the plan is, why it makes sense, and why it’s worth it.  And because all the outward signs are negative, the leader has to talk about it a lot more than they expect to.
  2. The organization must have an investment mindset.  They must look past the short term; they must think in business growth terms like “cost per new donor” and “lifetime value.”  If the Board or anyone else is overly focused on short-term ROI, the nonprofit will cancel the program too early, leaving itself with most of the expenses and almost none of the new donors.
  3. Finally, the person leading the effort must get good advice.  Talk to acquisition experts.  Pick the brains of larger nonprofits who have established donor acquisition programs – they will happily share the lessons they’ve learned.

The chances of figuring out scalable donor acquisition on your own is unlikely, but thankfully it’s unnecessary.  You are not alone – other organizations have been down this road before!

If You Really Want to Acquire More New Donors, Read This

Make “The Leap” to Acquire a LOT of new donors

We’ve been asked a LOT lately about acquiring new donors.  (I don’t think this is a coincidence given that the number of individual donors in the U.S. decreased last year.)

If you want to learn about how bigger nonprofits acquire significant numbers of new donors every year, please take a look at the blog post below.  I wrote it in 2018 and every word is still relevant. 

Spoiler alert: there is no silver bullet.  There’s a skill you have to learn.  But the path is knowable.  And the great news is that lots of nonprofits have gone on the path before and will gladly share what they’ve learned to help you.

Happy reading!


This post is about acquiring new donors.

But it’s for nonprofits at a very specific stage in their development.

Keep reading if the following three things are true for your organization:

  • You’re actively trying to grow
  • You realize that to achieve that growth you need more new donors each year than you’ve been acquiring
  • You know that your current ways of acquiring new donors won’t achieve your new goals

I’ll give you an example. We work with a handful of organizations that have between 500 and 4,000 donors. These organizations want to grow… but the ways they acquire new donors are labor-intensive and are hard to expand:

  • Tours of their facility
  • An event or two a year
  • Word of mouth
  • A major donor connects them to another major donor
  • Vision Meetings

All good things – but small nonprofits can only do so many of them each year.

So the organization is stuck: they want to grow, know they need more donors, but don’t have the staff to do more.

If That’s You, What Do You Do?

If that’s you, please know that you’re in good company. A LOT of organizations are in your shoes.

But your question remains: how do you begin to acquire significantly more new donors than you have in the past?

It starts with thinking differently about acquiring donors. The Big Idea is that there is a cost associated with acquiring new donors. You’re going to need to pay for the attention of potential donors via media like radio, the mail, Facebook ads, etc.

In my experience, most smaller nonprofits never make the leap from homegrown, labor-intensive methods of acquiring donors. These smaller nonprofits don’t want to pay (or don’t think they can’t afford) the costs needed to do this.

But if they really want to grow, they need to.

Making the Leap

Below are my tips for “making the leap” to a new way of acquiring new donors.

And I need to say right away that I’m not providing the solution to your donor acquisition problem. This is not “7 easy tricks to more donors than you can count!” (That post would probably get a lot of readers, but it wouldn’t hold water because there is no silver bullet.)

The Current Situation

Most small nonprofits have no line item in the budget for donor acquisition. They also really don’t know their current cost for every donor acquired, because those costs are buried in other expenses.

For example, they might spend $50,000 on an event that acquires 100 new donors. But the expenses are only looked at in relation to how much revenue came in, not how many new donors were acquired.

What’s needed is a dedicated budget for donor acquisition.

How to Grow

Smaller nonprofits basically have two options for growth. You can pursue either one, or both:

  1. Start a scalable Donor Acquisition program. This means doing specific activities like buying radio spots and/or mailing lists, upping your online donor acquisition game, etc.
    • For example: doing a radio share-a-thon for $15,000, getting 500 new donors, then doing that every year moving forward. And this is scalable because you could do two radio share-a-thons for $30,000 and acquire 1,000 new donors. Or 3 radio share-a-thons for $45,000 and acquire 1,500 new donors.
  2. Do more of what you’re currently doing. (For clarity’s sake, I would define what most smaller orgs are doing in donor acquisition as not scalable. Could you expand your event and get 250 more donors? Maybe. Could you add three more events and get 750 new donors? Probably not.)

In my experience, “doing more of what you’re currently doing” almost never results in the type of growth a motivated organization is looking for.

So they have to bite the bullet. They have to pay the costs to start up a donor acquisition program.

Ask a Good Question

The most successful organization leaders, when they want to grow, are asking one of these questions:

  • “I have $XX,XXX to spend on getting new donors in 2018. How many new donors could we get for that?”
  • “I need X,XXX new donors in 2018. How much is it going to cost me?”
  • “By 2020 I need to have our income be 50% higher than 2017. How many new donors do we need to reach that level, and how much will it cost?”

If you know how much you have to spend, we can estimate how many new donors you can acquire.

If you know how many new donors you want to acquire, we can estimate how much it will cost you.

If you know how much you want to be raising 5 years from now, based on how your current donors are performing, we can tell you how many new donors you’ll need, to reach your goals.

Helpful Big Ideas

For organizations who want to begin scalable donor acquisition, there’s a set of ideas that more-or-less must be present in your organization for it to work:

  • If your organization is serious about acquiring new donors, you’ll have a line item in your budget for Donor Acquisition.
  • Measuring the Cost Per New Donor is a sign of maturity for an organization. It means you’re running the thing like a business, with known (and measured) inputs and known (and predictable) outcomes.
  • Scalable methods of donor acquisition require an investment mindset. Usually in donor acquisition you lose money in the short term, but you make money in the long term. For example, you might spend $1,000 and get 10 donors who each give you $50. So you spent $1,000 to raise $500. BUT, if you do a good job retaining those 10 donors they’ll give you $3,000 over the course of their time with you. So you actually spent $1,000 to raise $3,000.
  • There’s no way to know exactly how much a new donor will cost for an organization without testing. But there are industry standards and deep experience for every media channel – even Instagram, believe it or not. Find somebody or some organization who is doing a lot of donor acquisition, and ask them. In my experience, people will help you.
  • The Cost Per New Donor is always higher when you first start scalable acquisition methods. That’s because you do not know what will work best. Over time, you figure out which messages and mediums work best, and the cost per new donor comes down over time. (This is another reason it’s so important to have an investment mindset when you start to scale your acquisition.)
  • There is a “minimum level of investment” to start a donor acquisition program. For instance, if a radio share-a-thon costs $20k and gets you 200 donors, you can’t buy half a share-a-thon for $10,000 and get 100 donors. And by the way, Dear Reader, I don’t think you need to hear this. But I share it because there’s always someone on a Board that says, “Could we just buy seven commercials and see if that works?” What you want to do is figure out what the “minimum effective test” is, and do that. Not half of that.

Moving to this type of donor acquisition is a great sign of growth and maturity for an organization. It’s almost always a sign of a nonprofit being run like a business – and I mean that in the best way possible. It’s being a great steward of the resources given to us by donors to maximize their impact.

Good luck out there – and get in touch if you’d like to talk about donor acquisition!

This post was originally published on September 13, 2018.